The Many Lawsuits of Donald Trump: Constitutional Edition


Trump has always been a magnet for litigation. Hell, he’s being sued by a PORN STAR at the moment. And there’s a whole Wikipedia page just on his lawsuits. But you may not know that Trump is being sued for violations of the Constitution of the United States. And not a moment too soon!

Trump is being sued by the District of Columbia (AKA Washington D.C.) and Maryland, represented by their respective attorneys general. Both claim Trump has been illegally enriching himself via the office of President, violating both the Foreign Emoluments Clause and the Domestic Emoluments Clause of the Constitution. Here’s the money-shot quote from the lawsuit itself:

President Trump, acting through companies he owns or controls, has violated both the Foreign Emoluments Clause and the Domestic Emoluments Clause by receiving millions of dollars in payments, benefits, and other valuable consideration from foreign governments and persons acting on their behalf, as well as federal agencies and state governments. His repeated, ongoing violations include remuneration derived from: (a) leases of Trump properties held by foreign-government-owned entities; (b) purchase and ownership of condominiums in Trump properties by foreign governments or foreign-government-controlled entities; (c) other property interests or business dealings tied to foreign governments; (d) hotel accommodations, restaurant purchases, the use of venues for events, and purchases of other services and goods by foreign governments and diplomats at hotels, restaurants, and other domestic and international properties owned, operated, or licensed by President Trump; (e) continuation of the General Services Administration lease for President Trump’s Washington, D.C. hotel despite his breach of the lease’s terms, and potential provision of federal tax credits in connection with the same property; and (f) payments from foreign-government-owned broadcasters related to rebroadcasts and foreign versions of the television program “The Apprentice” and its spinoffs.

What’s this all mean?

donald trump lawsuits trump hotel dc
Image credit: Maxence

The suit charges that Washington D.C. has suffered damages because visiting dignitaries and heads of state will no longer stay at non-Trump hotels. Because why would they? If you could stay at a Trump property when visiting Trump, wouldn’t that make him like you more?

A tin-pot dictator like Trump probably asks folks if they stayed at his hotels. “Did you shit in the golden toilets?” I’m sure he asks. As a result, property owners in D.C. are losing money while the President uses his position of influence to enrich himself.

Maryland also claims the “sovereign right” to sue to enforce the Constitution. This is a right shared by all states but held in especially high regard by Maryland. And the state may even have enhanced standing here, thanks to their long history of supporting the Emoluments Clause going back 350 years.

The aim of the lawsuit is to get President Trump to divest from his many properties or step down as President. Option number 2, please!

Will it work?

donald trump lawsuits supreme court building

Well, this is an amended complaint for an ongoing lawsuit. It’s been in court since June 2017, so it’s not brand-new news. But it is the first time a government has sued a president for violating the Emoluments Clause. Of the other lawsuits alleging violations of the clasue, this one seems the most likely to succeed.

So will it work? It’s impossible to say. But it does sound good. The plaintiffs have standing and seem to have a decent case. Plus the suit is far from frivolous, especially since it was brought by state governments, not some individual claiming they were harmed by the President.

Nothing may come of it. But heck, we’re fricken stoked about this ourselves.


Alex Fox

0 Comments

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.